Trap
NormalMischief of the Gnomes
View:
4597
This turn, reduce the Levels of all monsters in each player's hand by 1 (even after they are Summoned/Set). You can banish this card from the Graveyard; this turn, reduce the Levels of all monsters in each player's hand by 1 (even after they are Summoned/Set).
Mischief of the Gnomes — Power Evaluation
Final Score: 53 ± 6 · Confidence: Medium
- Intrinsic: 54 · Deck: 52 · Meta: provisional
- Primary role: Floodgate/Control · Secondary: Utility
Why it scores here
Mischief of the Gnomes scores as a situational disruption tool that trades power generation for accessibility and splashability. Its strength lies in broad distribution across 87 archetypes with flexible 1-2 of inclusion enabled by GY recursion providing a secondary activation route. However, zero involvement in winning combo lines, symmetric disruption affecting both players equally, and metagame-dependent utility prevent a higher score. The card is best understood as a defensive tech effective specifically against level-dependent strategies like Synchro and Rank-based decks, not as a power generator.
Axis scores
| Axis | Score | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Accessibility | 62 | Present in 87 archetypes with 1.27 copies average and GY recursion route; normal trap timing limits live access (verified: deck stats, text). |
| Combo & Conversion | 15 | Zero appearances in recorded combo lines; text analysis shows no board generation or resource return (verified: combo data). |
| Resource Economy | 35 | One-card cost with no direct advantage return; GY recursion is secondary activation, not refund (verified: card text). |
| Effect & Interaction | 58 | Situational disruption effective versus level-dependent strategies like Synchro and Rank decks; weak against low-level starters (inferred: card text + metagame logic). |
| Material Utility | 5 | Trap card with no material usage for any summon method (verified: card type). |
| Resilience & Flexibility | 52 | GY recursion provides secondary activation; effect is one-time per turn; vulnerable to trap removal like MST (inferred: card text). |
| Deck-Building Efficiency | 72 | Highly splashable tech with no deck-building locks or garnet concerns; flexible 1-2 of across 87 archetypes (observed: deck distribution, archetype spread). |
Calculation
Weight profile: 0.7 Floodgate/Control + 0.3 Utility. Intrinsic ≈ 54, Deck ≈ 52, Meta = provisional. Modifiers: none. Final formula: 0.40*Intrinsic + 0.60*Deck
Strengths
- Highly splashable across 87 distinct archetypes with no deck-building restrictions
- Dual activation routes: hand setup plus GY recursion for flexibility and redundancy
- Persistent level reduction via 'even after they are Summoned/Set' clause catches newly summoned threats
- Viable as flexible 1-2 of tech inclusion in control-oriented decks
- No garnet or brick concerns; normal traps naturally support multiple copies
Weaknesses
- Symmetric disruption affects both players equally, diluting net advantage gain
- Effect is temporary ('this turn' only); no cross-turn persistence or lock
- Highly situational utility; weak against low-level starters and strategies unrelated to level
- Zero involvement in recorded winning combo lines despite 400 matched decks
- Requires setup timing as normal trap; vulnerable to Mystical Space Typhoon and Cosmic Cyclone
- GY recursion requires manual banish; not automatic like on-summon or on-effect triggers
Counters / choke points
- Trap removal: Mystical Space Typhoon, Cosmic Cyclone, and similar effects
- Decks running primarily low-level starters unaffected by level reduction
- Quick-play trap negation available to opponent
- High-level hand traps capable of negating trap activation
Best use
Situational hand disruption tech against level-dependent strategies. Decks: Eldlich, D/D/D, Control-focused variants, Fiendsmith.
Evidence & gaps
- Verified: Card is a Normal Trap with dual-effect design: hand activation and GY recursion; Runs in 400 matched decks at 1.27 copies average across 87 distinct archetypes; Legal in all four formats (TCG, OCG, MasterDuel, DuelLinks) with no banlist restrictions; Effect reduces all monsters in both players' hands by 1 Level with persistent application clause; Top partners are generic staples (Ash Blossom, Triple Tactics Thrust, Mulcharmy), confirming tech card role
- Observed: 78% of decks using this card are Control-type; only 13.5% are Combo-type (gameplay distribution); Zero appearances in recorded combo lines despite 400 matched decks (combo data: 0 appearances); Average 1.27 copies per deck with distribution skewed toward 1-copy shows flexible tech inclusion pattern; Highest presence in Eldlich (26 decks), D/D/D (25), Fiendsmith (24), confirming home in control strategies; Distinct archetype spread of 87 indicates true splashability across deck types
- Inferred: The 'even after they are Summoned/Set' clause creates persistent level reduction during a single turn, catching newly summoned threats mid-combo; GY recursion provides a secondary activation route after initial trap resolution, increasing flexibility; Level reduction disruption is most effective against Synchro-dependent and Rank-based combo strategies; minimal impact against all-in-one starter types; Symmetric effect means its net value is metagame-dependent, maximizing utility when opponent runs high-level engines
- Data gaps: No combos supplied — zero combo appearances is a major signal indicating limited involvement in winning lines, but cannot distinguish between niche card and genuinely weak combo tool No usage statistics (StatisticsCard) — archetype inclusion percentages are sample-derived only; cross-metagame consistency cannot be confirmed No banlist token — assumed unlimited at 3 copies; recent limiting would significantly impact score Minimal guide context — only 1 brief Duel Links mention; human analysis of metagame role is absent Symmetric effect value is metagame-dependent — true power score oscillates with opponent deck composition






